THOIA follower,
Otto, emailed me looking for some answers to a comic cover he remembered seeing at a grocery store over half a century ago, and I believe this
Ross Andru / Mike Esposito pair-up from
Mystery Tales #16 (1964) fits the bill. Now if you clicked the
GCD link in the previous sentence, you undoubtably noticed that the story itself actually originated in the Sept '52 issue of
Tales of Horror #2, that's because
Mystery Tales #16 is simply a complete reprint of that entire issue, just with brand spankin' new cover art. This story also found its way into
Haunted Horror #4 in 2013.