"Oh rats!", said the anti-Atlas oddballs. Yep, it's another riveting tale from the May 1952 issue of Mystery Tales #2, (see the previous post as well.) And some of you proud precoders probably don't even need to look at the signature in the splash panel to know the late great Bill Everett when you see it!
And thanks to the Atlas Tales site for the first page scan of this story, it's unfortunately missing from my tattered old copy. --K